Strolling in my garden, I noticed weeds in some areas of the pathways. I leaned down to pull one of the undesired plants and felt the resistance from the weed fabric I laid five years ago. My first thought was this weed barrier is not doing a good job, and I should get a stronger one and redo the pathways. As the days passed by, I decided to take it off altogether instead, and here are my 6 reasons why weed fabric is not worth it for me.

6 reasons weed fabric is nor worth the hype

#1 It not a permanent solution

Laying landscape fabric before putting on gravel or mulch is, in fact, a quick solution for a long-term problem. Indeed, you may succeed to block undesired plants coming from the ground up, but that’s only for a short period of time. As the seasons go by, birds and natural elements drop seeds, which, eventually, sprout and grow into a full plant. Also, Organic matter, such as tree leaves and dirt, settles in between the fabric and the mulch or gravel, creating a growing medium for the weeds.

#2 Makes weeding difficult

The truth is that some plants are strong and resilient, such as bermudagrass in Texas. This grass is hard to kill and is quite invasive to its surrounding areas. It always finds its way through any obstacle thanks to its runners.

Bermuda can grow through the fabric and ruin your hard work. The hardest part is that it is even more difficult to pull up because Its roots weave themselves within the fabric.

Other plants, such as dandelions and nutsedge, also send roots through the fabric, preventing the gardener from pulling the whole root system when weeding.

puddles in the garden

#3 Not permeable enough

During heavy rains, the soil needs more time to absorb all the extra flow of water. When you have a weed barrier laid, that time is even longer. Also, the puddles, forming all over the pathways, cause the mulch to float away. This problem is minimal in areas where there is no weed fabric.

6 reasons  weed fabric is not worth the hype

#4 Ends soil improvement

While pulling some weed, I noticed the old mulch has turned into beautiful soil, which reminded me of the “Back-to-Eden” gardening method. Unfortunately, having the heavy-duty weed barrier blocks this composted wood from improving the native soil. The revealed soil was extremely compacted and full of cracks.

#5 Turns the soil anaerobic

As mentioned previously about the water not getting through the fabric fast enough, the same applies to air. Having the weed fabric covering native soil does not allow good air circulation. This may cause some unpleasant smells in the yard, especially after rainfall.

#6 Interfers with soil’s biological life

Soil is full of life, and the living organisms that make up this life rely on different natural elements to survive. Having the weed barrier blocks many of those elements, such as air and light. It also prevents crawling insects from traveling around the surface of the soil.

#7 Not ecofriendly

Weed fabric is made out of petroleum-derived material that may harm plants by leaching harmful chemicals. Also, like plastic, it is not biodegradable, which will increase waste. Using more of this material will only add to the damage we are already causing on this earth. As gardeners, we should work with nature and not against it.

#8 Unecessary expense

When starting a garden, the cost of material can add quite significantly. Weed fabric is one of those expenses you can easily skip.

why weed fabric is not worth the hype

Making a better choice

In my case, I decided to get rid of all weed fabric in my pathways. I laid mulch straight on the ground. This won’t eliminate weeds, but removing them will be much easier.

Another solution is to lay a thick layer of cardboard before putting the mulch. This will block sunlight and smother the weeds before it decomposes and enriches the soil.

Another solution is leaving the grass around the raised beds. You may place stepping stones to define the pathways. Make sure, however, to leave ample space in between the beds for the lawnmower. Cutting the grass regularly will reduce the number of weeds eventually.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.